Comfort is on the Horizon

Heat Pump vs. Furnace: Which Is Best for Your Florida Home

Heat Pump vs. Furnace: Which Is Best for Your Florida Home

Many homes in Florida do not have heating systems. Some homeowners aiming to heat their Florida residence may find themselves starting from square one. They must decide exactly what kind of system they want and consider any relevant details surrounding it.

Our expert technicians are here for youSchedule Online Today

This typically leads to a debate between heat pumps and furnaces. Both systems have their advantages and disadvantages that must be carefully weighed when making a decision.

So, what are these advantages and disadvantages? What is the difference between a heat pump and a furnace? Is one definitely better than the other? Keep reading to discover the answers to these questions and more.

What Is a Heat Pump?

Heat Pumps vs. Furnaces: 4 Differences & Primary Components

Most traditional heaters generate hot air by heating something up. However, heat pumps operate differently. They work by transferring heat from one place to another. The most common type is an air-source heat pump. These units transfer heat from the air itself. However, this requires some heat to exist outside of the home, so they are not as effective in particularly cold climates.

What Is a Furnace?

Both gas and electric furnaces work by using an energy source (either burning fuel or using electricity) to create heat, which is then distributed through your home by a fan or blower.

  • Oil and natural gas furnaces: As you may have guessed, these work by burning oil or natural gas. The heat from this reaction is then used by the furnace to heat the house.
  • Electric furnaces: These work by running an electrical current through a piece of metal until it heats up.

Which System Is More Efficient?

In general, heat pumps are far more efficient than furnaces because they are simply moving heat, not actively heating something. Think of it like moving a candle from one room to another, as opposed to lighting a new candle.

However, this isn’t true in extremely cold winters, which cause inefficiencies and can even push heat pumps to the point where heat pump repair is necessary. However, a heat pump in Florida will generally not have this problem, as our winters tend to be milder. 

Which HVAC System Is More Versatile?

Overall, furnaces are slightly more versatile than heat pumps. They work in more climates, as a heat pump won’t work as well in particularly cold climates. Furnaces also allow you to choose a source of energy that works best for you.

However, heat pumps have the edge in one specific way. They can be reversed and used as AC units as well as heaters.

heat pump outside a home

Other Factors to Consider:

  • Installation costs: Heat pump installation tends to be the cheaper of the two options. 
  • Safety: Heat pumps are considered to be safer than furnaces. This is primarily because many furnaces come with a risk of leaking carbon monoxide, which is incredibly deadly. 
  • Lifespan: Heat pumps and furnaces typically need to be replaced after 10 to 15 years.

Why Choose Fenwick

If you are interested in either a heat pump or a furnace, you will need an HVAC professional to help you install your new system. In this case, look no further than Fenwick Home Services

At Fenwick, we handle all types of heating and cooling jobs. We can use our extensive knowledge of heating systems to help you pick the right system for you and install it ourselves. With us, you can trust that you’ll get the right system and have it put in correctly. Even after the system is installed, we’ll be there for you for any future heating maintenance or heating repair jobs you have. 


Heat pumps are often a better choice for Florida homes compared to traditional furnaces because they offer both heating and cooling capabilities in one system. This versatility is ideal for Florida’s climate, which experiences hot summers and milder winters. 

Heat pumps are more energy-efficient and cost-effective for maintaining comfort throughout the year. They work by transferring heat instead of burning fuel, making them an environmentally friendly choice. 

Additionally, they are safer and don’t involve combustion processes, which can reduce safety concerns. Overall, heat pumps provide a practical and efficient solution for Florida’s unique weather conditions. Nonetheless, since each home is unique and the requirements of individual homeowners can differ, it’s advisable to seek the advice of a licensed HVAC company, like Fenwick, before reaching a decision.